Taste of Philly - Greeley Menu
Welcome to Taste of Philly - Greeley, your go-to destination for authentic Philadelphia flavors right in the heart of Greeley, CO. Located at 829 16th St, this vibrant eatery is known for its incredible sandwiches, particularly the Original Philly cheesesteak and the savory Ruben, both of which have garnered rave reviews from locals and visitors alike.
Customer experiences highlight the warm hospitality, with staff like Dillon and Destiny making every visit memorable. Many patrons praise the fresh, delicious food that’s even better when enjoyed on-site, underscoring the inviting atmosphere. Desserts here have earned a reputation for being extraordinary, making them a must-try.
Whether you’re a cheesesteak novice or a seasoned aficionado, at Taste of Philly, you’ll find a genuine slice of Philly charm, complete with friendly service and a cozy setting that beckons you to return.
Specialties
Chicken Tenders
3 Italian breaded fried chicken tenders, served with french fries and dipping sauce
Fish N' Chip RG
Meatball Parmesan RG
Choice of protein with provolone, marinara, and parmesan cheese
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Grilled sourdough and white american cheese.
Grilled Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Grilled sourdough, white american cheese, grilled ham.
Reuben Sandwich
You think you’ve had a Reuben? Think again. This isn’t just a sandwich – it’s an experience. Corned beef as tender as it gets, Swiss cheese that melts like butter, tangy sauerkraut, and thousand island dressing all grilled to perfection between two slices of crispy rye. This is what a real Reuben tastes like, and if you haven’t tried it yet – you’re missing out.
Meatball Parmesan LG
Choice of protein with provolone, marinara, and parmesan cheese
BLT Sandwich
Bacon lettuce tomato and mayo, on grilled sourdough. It's really good.
12" French Dip
Freshly sliced pastrami with spicy mustard, red onions, tomato's, and provolone cheese
Philly Of The Sea Rg
Fried Cod with tarter sauce, Cheddar Cheese, and your choice of toppings
Club Sandwich
Turkey, ham, bacon, swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Layered between 3 slices of grilled sourdough.
Deli Sandwich/Melt
Your custom creation. Choose meat cheese veggies and bread.
Fish N' Chip LG
8 Jumbo Wings
8 jumbo fried wings sauced and tossed in your choice of up to 2 sauces
16 Jumbo Wings
16 jumbo fried wings sauced and tossed in your choice of up to 2 sauces
12 Jumbo Wings
12 jumbo fried wings sauced and tossed in your choice of up to 2 sauces
Wings
8" Cheesesteaks
8" Mushroom Cheesesteak
Grilled mushrooms and onions, chopped steak, white american cheese
8" Hoagie Philly Cheesesteak
Lettuce, tomato, grilled onions, chopped steak, white american cheese
8" Original Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, chopped steak, white american cheese
8" Works Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, peppers, and mushrooms, chopped steak, white american cheese
8" Hot Popper Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, jalapenos, chopped steak, and cream cheese
8" Roasted Red Philly
Grilled onions, chopped steak, roasted red peppers, garlic, provolone cheese
8" Green Chile Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, green chile, chopped steak, cheddar cheese
8" Pepper Cheesesteak
Grilled bell peppers and onions, chopped steak, white american cheese
8" Chicken Philly Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, chopped chicken, white american cheese
8" Pizza Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, chopped steak, marinara sauce, with melted provolone and parmesan cheese
8" Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, chopped chicken, buffalo sauce, provolone cheese, and choice of ranch or bleu cheese
12" Ham
Sliced ham with your choice of cheese and toppings
12" Turkey
Sliced turkey with your choice of cheese and toppings
12" Italian
Sliced ham, salami, capicola, and provolone cheese, with your choice of toppings.
12" Veggie
Your choice of cheese, and fresh or grilled veggies on an Amoroso roll
12" Club Hoagie
Turkey ham bacon and swiss, with your choice of toppings.
12" Hoagies & Grinders
Salads
Chef Salad LG
Large tossed salad topped with sliced turkey, ham, and cheese
Cheesesteak Salad SM
Our tossed salad with steak, grilled onions, and american cheese on top
Tossed Salad LG
Hand crafted with romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red and green bell pepper, red onion, mushroom, olive, and cherry pepper with your choice of dressing.
Tossed Salad SM
Hand crafted with romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red and green bell pepper, red onion, mushroom, olive, and cherry pepper with your choice of dressing.
Crispy Chicken SM
Our tossed salad with a grilled and sliced chicken breast on top
Cheesesteak Salad LG
Our large tossed salad topped with steak, grilled onions, and american cheese
Chef Salad SM
Our tossed salad with a sliced turkey/ham/cheese roll on top
Crispy Chicken LG
12" Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, chopped chicken, buffalo sauce, provolone cheese, choice of ranch or bleu cheese
12" Works Cheesesteak
Grilled onions mushrooms and bell peppers, chopped steak, white american cheese
12" Mushroom Cheesesteak
Grilled mushrooms and onions, chopped steak, white american cheese
12" Chicken Philly Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, chopped chicken, white american cheese
12" Hot Popper Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, jalapenos, cream cheese, chopped steak
12" Original Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, chopped steak, white american cheese
12" Pepper Cheesesteak
Grilled bell peppers and onions, chopped steak, white american cheese
12" Roasted Red Philly
Grilled onions, roasted red peppers, garlic, chopped steak, provolone cheese
12" Pizza Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, marinara sauce, chopped steak, provolone and parmesan cheese
12" Hoagie Philly Cheesesteak
Lettuce, tomato, grilled onions, chopped steak, white american cheese
12" Green Chile Cheesesteak
Grilled onions, green chile, chopped steak, cheddar cheese
12" Cheesesteaks
Kids
Kids Ham & Cheese
On white bread with white american cheese
Kids Tenders W/ Fries
2 chicken tenders with a small french fry and choice of dipping sauce
Kids Philly (6")
Kids Grilled Cheese
Small grilled cheese on white bread with white american cheese
Green Chile Cheese Curds W/ Ranch
Fried crispy cheese curds
French Fries LG
Cheese Fries SM
Covered in cheese wiz
Potato Salad SM
French Fries SM
Chips
Green Chile Fries LG
Topped with cheese wiz and green chile
Cheese Fries LG
Covered in cheese wiz
Green Chile Fries SM
Topped with cheese wiz and green chile
Battered Mushrooms W/ Ranch
Beer battered fried mushrooms
Onions Rings LG
Green Chile Cheese Curds LG
Battered Mushrooms LG
Onion Rings SM
Potato Salad LG
Pretzel Bites
12 warm salted pretzel bites served with choice of cheese or mustard
Sides
Drinks
Hanks
6 Pack Soda
Dasani
Enhanced with a proprietary blend of minerals to give it the clean, fresh taste you want from water.
Can Soda
Mexican Coke
1 liter big boys
8" Club Hoagie
Turkey ham bacon and swiss, with your choice of toppings.
8" Veggie
Your choice of cheese, and fresh or grilled veggies on an Amoroso roll
8" Ham
Sliced ham with your choice of cheese and toppings
8" Italian
Sliced ham, salami, capicola, and provolone cheese, with your choice of toppings.
8" Turkey
Sliced turkey with your choice of cheese and toppings
8" Hoagies & Grinders
Desserts
(1x) Cannoli
Fried cinnamon shell filled with chocolate chips and sweet mascarpone cheese
NY Style Cheesecake
(2x) Cannoli's
Fried cinnamon shell filled with chocolate chips and sweet mascarpone cheese
Brickfire Brownie
Rich chocolate brownie with a cheesecake swirl throughout